NP News

Unjust ICJ genocide ruling lacks judicial consensus

Htet Nadi/ Thant Zin(NP News)- Nov 22
On November 19, an unjust ruling was delivered by a 9-6 majority in the case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar over alleged violations of the 1948 Genocide Convention. The Gambia filed the lawsuit over allegations that the Tatmadaw committed genocide against Bengalis during clearance operations in northern Rakhine State in 2017. Following a seven-year legal defense from 2019 until the ruling in 2026, Myanmar has ultimately been branded once again as a state guilty of genocide.
The judgment has been described as a historic first in holding a state directly responsible for committing genocide. However, in the court's initial ruling involving 15 judges, it was decided by 9 votes in favor and 6 votes against that Myanmar had failed to prevent and punish genocide. This clearly shows that the decision was not reached by the unanimous will of all the judges, and the court issued a 13-point ruling as its final decision in the case.
Dr. Khaing Khaing Soe, Spokeperson of the President Office remarked on the delivery of the judgment at the second press conference of the President's Office on November 20, “Even now when delivering the ruling, as just mentioned, it was not an order agreed upon by all 15 judges. Nine to six is not a wide margin in percentage terms. So it was also not a consensus of everyone. And what was just said about it not being fair is true. From my position to state this, I say that this is not fair."
Even so, out of goodwill to respect and abide by international law, Myanmar engaged constructively to address the suit filed at the ICJ by a small nation like The Gambia, which has no direct relevance or connection to the matter. In reality, The Gambia is a small country in West Africa that would not be able to spend vast sums of money to bring a case before an international court like the ICJ. Behind it, however, stands a major organization like the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), and it was with that organization's support that The Gambia was able to bring this case.
Regarding the step-by-step legal and factual arguments presented by Myanmar during the proceedings, an official from Myanmar's Ministry of Foreign Affairs explained at the press conference on November 20, "The ICJ issued some provisional measures against Myanmar. Then we raised preliminary objections against what The Gambia submitted. However, because the court rejected them, we have now reached the merits stage and submitted written pleadings and oral arguments twice each." Moreover, Myanmar also complied with and implemented the provisional measures ordered by the court.
In the findings and statements within the ruling, it was stated that 392 villages were attacked during the Tatmadaw's clearance operations, whereas the security posts and police outposts attacked on Myanmar's side were not mentioned. Regarding this, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs official stated: "In 2017, ARSA carried out coordinated, simultaneous attacks on 25 security posts, 30 police outposts, and battalions. Those records also show everything was planned in advance. We made our utmost effort to submit these matters with full evidence to the ICJ."
The official further explained: "We argued and presented the truth of the events. In addition, we presented the Myanmar government's efforts to repatriate and receive back those who were displaced following the incidents. So what we want to convey is that Myanmar is a responsible country, and on the other hand a country that participated in good faith in the Genocide Convention, as well as a country that values justice."
Nevertheless, disregarding Myan­mar's submissions and making a ruling by unfairly slapping on labels as one pleases is quite severe. That is because the clearance operations were carried out in pursuit of safeguarding the country's sovereignty and territorial stability, and during those operations, weapons of high destructive power—such as aerial bombings or heavy artillery—were never used to an extent that would warrant being branded as genocide. Instead of taking these circumstances into account, the ICJ repeatedly cited and relied upon the claim submitted by The Gambia that 10,000 Bengalis had died.
On the other hand, the court overlooked the deaths of ethnic Rakhine people and Hindus in northern Rakhine State, as well as local smaller ethnic groups such as the Mro, Khami, Kaman and Thet, who were killed by ARSA terrorists.
This case can also be said to have been brought by The Gambia and the OIC circle seeking political and other gains to have those they call "Rohingya" recognized as citizens of Myanmar. However, that demand made by The Gambia was rejected because it went beyond the court's decision-making authority. That matter pertains to Myanmar's existing 1982 Citizenship Law.
This was a demand in which the Islamic countries' expectations did not match the outcome. In another sense, it was also an attempt to use the judiciary to gain political advantage.
Accordingly, on November 19, following an agreement among the United States, China, and Russia, a statement was issued noting that "the three heads of state recognized that the principle of state consent and respect for immunities of State officials are of paramount importance, and concurred that the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction." International organizations therefore should not manipulate judicial mechanisms at will against countries they wish to label.
Ultimately, because this ICJ judgment was not reached unanimously but passed by a narrow 9-to-6 vote, it remains an undeniable fact that six judges understood and accepted the reality of Myanmar's case. External pressures and politically driven rulings will neither resolve complex internal challenges nor contribute to lasting peace on the ground. True justice can be achieved only when international judicial mechanisms remain free from political instrumentalization, and are able to assess the actual realities of a sovereign state impartially. In short, the ICJ has undermined its own credibility by unwisely allowing geopolitical narratives to overshadow objective legal scrutiny.

မူရင်းသတင်း — NP News