
Phyo (NP News) - Nov 16
The International Court of Justice (ICJ), based in The Hague, the Netherlands, is set to deliver its final judgment on November 19 in the case brought by the Gambia against Myanmar over alleged violations of the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.Commenting on the forthcoming ruling, Dr. Aye Maung told The Statesman Journal that the Myanmar government would not necessarily accept every aspect of the ICJ's final judgement.
After the final verdict is handed down on November 19, there will be no right to appeal the verdict and all court proceedings will be completed.
Regarding the possibility of a decision on the situation to be decided on November 19, Dr. Aye Maung, an expert on Rakhine State affairs and chairman of the Arakan Front Party, said, “Others say three things. The first is that the issue of genocide could be a big one. They also say that it could be between the two sides, based on Myanmar’s request. But they also say that they will not give Myanmar any concessions.”
Dr. Aye Maung said that if the actions were classified as war crimes rather than genocide, it would mean that the Bengali had staged mass incidents to portray Myanmar in a negative light, regardless of how strongly Myanmar maintained that its operations were clearance operations.
“They will have to be accepted back. For that purpose, a designated zone will need to be established, possibly with some form of fencing or barrier. This could be introduced on the grounds of protecting their human dignity. If a legal judgment is made using the name they refer to, the Rakhine public will not accept the Muslim community being recognized as ‘Rohingya’ under that name. I also think the Myanmar government will not accept it,” he said.
Dr. Aye Maung believes that the Myanmar government will not accept every point made by the ICJ. If they apply for citizenship, they will be scrutinized according to the 1982 Myanmar Citizenship Law, and they can choose not to comply with the court's decision.
“From what we have heard, ICJ rulings are not necessarily something that must be followed unconditionally. For a ruling to be strictly enforced, the authority of the United Nations Security Council would be required. Even in that situation, I believe there are Security Council member states that would support the government. If the ICJ, together with the UN Security Council, makes a firm decision that Myanmar should not accept certain terms in order to protect the interests of the state and its citizens, the government would have to explain its position clearly so that the people understand and recognize the reasons behind it. If the government provides such an explanation, I believe that almost all citizens would accept it. By refusing to accept the ruling, the government might even gain greater political support, as nationalist sentiment could intensify,” Dr. Aye Maung said.
Regarding this incident, a Rakhine national who was present during the conflict in northern Rakhine State and who personally visited the areas where the incident occurred said that there was absolutely no genocide.
–
